How bad is aging for your gains?

Categories: Articles, Nutrition

As we age, we lose muscle mass and strength. This weakening with age is formally called sarcopenia: sarx means “flesh” in Greek and penia means “loss” or “low”. Nobody likes it, but it affects all of us, so you’re probably interested in what you can expect as you get older. At what age does sarcopenia set in and how bad is it?

 

Age of peak performance

It’s common to hear that in your 30s, everything starts to go downhill. Indeed, most top athletes of popular sports are in their 20s. For example, Olympic Weightlifters on average peak at age 26 [2]. However, the age of peak performance varies dramatically per sport from early 20s to the early 40s. Many top athletes retire not because they’re past their physical prime but because of injuries, drug-related health risks, better career opportunities or simply because they have nothing left to improve and don’t really need to work anymore for the rest of their life.

 

If we look specifically at sports where strength and muscle mass are the primary determinants of performance, athletes peak considerably later. Powerlifters reach their prime on average at age 35. Research on bodybuilders is scarce, in part because performance cannot be measured objectively, but if we look at the greatest bodybuilders of all time as judged by the Mr. Olympia competition, we can see that they were all in their prime until at least in their 30s.

  • Arnold Schwarzenegger, 7-time Mr. Olympia, made his comeback to win the 1980 Mr. Olympia in his early 30s before he re-retired.
  • Moving on to 1984, Lee Haney dominated the Mr. Olympia for a world-record 8 years until he retired undefeated in his early 30s.
  • Then Dorian Yates won the Mr. Olympia 6 consecutive times until he was in his mid 30s, after which he retired mainly due to injuries, not because he was defeated.
  • After Yates, Ronnie Coleman started his reign as the greatest bodybuilder on the planet for 8 years of Mr. Olympia until he was pushed down to a silver medal in his early 40s.
  • The bodybuilder that beat Coleman was Jay Cutler, who took the last of his 4 Mr. Olympia titles in his late 30s.
  • Currently, Phil Heath is in his 40s and still widely regarded as one of the most likely contenders for the next Mr. Olympia with 7 gold medals under his belt.

 

Lonnie gains after age 40

Lonnie hired me to prep for her first Bikini show at age 40. It turned into a 6-month competitive season with 3 top 3 placings, including being national champion of Denmark. I can vouch that she’s natural, as the reason she stopped competing was that she became pregnant.

 

How age affects your gains

These data are very much in line with those from scientific research by Lowndes et al. (2009). If we look at muscle growth and strength development after standardized strength training in 18- to 39-year-olds, there is no relation between age and the rate of muscle growth or isometric strength development. Age did seem to affect biceps curl 1RM strength development, but the researchers commented that “Although age was negatively associated with improvements in 1RM, the effect of age was small relative to the improvements induced through resistance training, thus suggesting age does not limit response to training in any practical way during early adulthood.”

 

But what about after age 40? Is age 40 the end of our prime? The fact top athletes on average are no longer in peak condition could be due to numerous factors other than age: enough money to move on, injuries, loss of motivation, injuries, side-effects from heavy drug use… did I mention injuries? When pushing your body to the limits for years on end in every way possible, it’s a matter of time before you get injured and at the world top, that can already mean the end of your prime.

 

Another way to look at this question is to see when sarcopenia sets in in the general population. As it turns out, muscle loss in the general population is well modeled by linear decline starting at age… 20. Look at the data below from Melton et al. (2015) and you can see muscle mass steadily decline over time as people get older. There is no ‘breaking point’. It’s slow but constant decay over time.

 

Loss of muscle mass with age

Source

 

What is going on here? How can sarcopenia set in in our 20s while powerlifters and bodybuilders stay in their prime until age 40 and scientific research shows our rate of gains also stays the same until at least age 40?

 

It’s because age is not the primary determinant of sarcopenia. Let me repeat that. Sarcopenia is not primarily a problem of age. Muscle biopsies suggest that muscle tissue does not suffer from age per se at all.

 

What does cause sarcopenia then? A scientific review on sarcopenia by Kim et al. (2010) concluded: “The primary causes of sarcopenia include a sedentary lifestyle and malnutrition.” Most people don’t get weak because they get older. They get weak because they spend their lives in front of the TV eating Doritos.

 

Research by Wroblewski et al. (2015) in high-level masters athletes found no significant loss of lean body mass or strength from 40 to 81 years of age in people that kept exercising. Now, if you look at the data, there are some downward trends and these were mostly endurance athletes, not bodybuilders pushing the limits of their genetic muscular potential, but heck, by age 81 most people have already passed away. The authors concluded: “This study contradicts the common observation that muscle mass and strength decline as a function of aging alone. Instead, these declines may signal the effect of chronic disuse rather than muscle aging.”

 

James body recomposition gains over age 50

At 53 years old with 7 years of lifting experience, James was looking great compared to the average 50 year old. But we could do better. After switching from a more conventional to a scientifically optimized training and nutrition program, he gained about 10 pounds of muscle while dropping from 15% to 10% body fat in under 4 months, as shown in 4 DXA scans over time.

 

Multiple scientific studies support that age per se is not the major cause of frailty in the elderly and does not affect our gains nearly as much as most people think.

  • In a study by Roth et al. (2001), elderly men and women aged 65-75 years gained just as much muscle as men and women in their 20s during 6 months of strength training. “The results indicate that neither age nor gender affects muscle volume response to whole-body strength training.”
  • Ivey et al. (2000) found no difference in muscle growth rates between trainees in their 20s and trainees around age 70. They concluded “Aging does not affect the muscle mass response to either strength training or detraining”.
  • In a study by Mayhew et al. (2009), a group of ~64-year-olds gained just as much muscle and strength as a group of ~27-year-olds during 4 months of strength training. They also had comparable anabolic gene expression, though there was reduced protein synthesis in the elderly. Going by the data, this may have been other lean body mass, like connective tissue, not myofibrillar protein (muscle tissue).
  • Loenneke et al. (2017) found no difference in the rate of muscle and strength development during strength training in 18-25 and 50-65-year-old women.

 

Ernestine Shepherd 82 year old bodybuilder

Ernestine Shepherd at age 82.

 

Even in your 90s your muscles remain responsive to strength training: 8 weeks of strength training increased strength by an average of 174% in one study.

 

Conclusion

It’s never too late to start lifting and always too early to stop. While competing with the best of the best in the world may not be realistic anymore after your mid 40s, you can always stay lean and you can likely retain the majority of your muscle mass all the way into your 80s. Exercise is truly a panacea. We evolved to run, hunt, travel, dance, live. Give your body what it needs, stay lean and fit, and it will serve you for many decades for a long and muscular life.


Mini Course on muscle building graphic Want more content like this?

Then get our free mini-course on muscle building, fat loss and strength.

By filling in your details you consent with our privacy policy and the way we handle your personal data.


About the author

Menno Henselmans

Formerly a business consultant, I've traded my company car to follow my passion in strength training. I'm now an online physique coach, scientist and international public speaker with the mission to help serious trainees master their physique.

» Join in and discuss this article on Facebook
Share via
>

Get our free course on how to build muscle, lose fat and get stronger.

14 lessons by Menno Henselmans, delivered straight to your inbox.

By filling in my details I consent with the privacy policy.

Send this to a friend