This Is The Optimal Body Fat % For Muscle Growth & Health
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
00:54 Why the goalposts keep moving
01:53 Finding your lower limit
02:43 Sustainable dieting is a skill
03:54 Fat loss, health, and longevity
04:59 Essential body fat and the BMI J-curve
07:31 Body fat and all-cause mortality
09:12 Mendelian randomization
11:00 Hormones, menstrual cycles, and fertility
13:56 Recovery, strength, and muscle growth
15:54 Optimal body fat ranges for men and women
17:49 How to find your own sustainable range
20:42 Outro
Transcript:
There is a right body fat percentage for your body to optimize health, aesthetics, and performance. At this body fat percentage, all of your problems in life will disappear and you will finally be content with your body. Okay, maybe not quite, but there is a range of optimal body fat for well-being. Well-being is what we ultimately do it for. Health, performance, and aesthetics only serve, in the end, to make us feel better. If it doesn’t make us feel better, then what’s the point?
Before I go into the science of each of these individual factors, I will give you some real talk, based on my 15-plus years of coaching and over 10 years of educating other coaches how to become better personal trainers, because there are a few very big life lessons that I found paramount, I think, for most people to understand when finding their optimal body fat percentage.
I’ve helped hundreds of individuals obtain and maintain their ideal body fat level, and I can tell you perfection is a moving target. You might think that if you’ve seen photos or you’ve looked at the data, you can just establish, “At 10% body fat, I will be happy.” And I can tell you it is not the case. You will forever want to get leaner. Let’s say you’re a guy that’s overweight, and right now your goal is just to be healthy. You want to not be overweight. When you’ve reached that point, you will want abs. And when you have abs, you will want a full six-pack. And when you have a full six-pack, you want to be shredded. The leaner you get and the more you progress, the further the goalpost keeps moving.
This means it’s much more important to focus on the process than the long-term outcome. Your goal should not be some specific body fat percentage, but rather a process that gets you to that point. This is where all the clichés come from, from fitness being a lifestyle, focusing on a journey. The joy is in the journey. All of these things are true. But there is a way to break the cycle.
Perfection is a moving target until you have crossed the targets. My one-sentence summary of this video is you should get too lean. I know the politically correct advice is not to focus too much on being lean, being content with where you are. Bullshit. The only way I’ve seen individuals be truly happy with their body fat percentage is when they’ve been too lean.
At some point, you will be so lean that you will experience the side effects of being lean. Low libido, low energy levels. Life just doesn’t feel good, even if you might be shredded. Only when you’ve actually hit that point and you’ve voluntarily decided, “I can get that lean. I know how to get that lean, but I’m not going to be that lean because it’s not worth it,” Only at that point can you truly accept a higher body fat level, in my experience.
Another large practical benefit of having been below your sustainable body fat level is that when you’ve completed the game on Ultra Mode, normal mode feels easy. Dieting is very much a skill. The better you are at dieting, the leaner you can sustainably get. You will optimize your food choices, your hunger management, and you can get to a lower body fat level while still feeling that you are satiated and satisfied, which are the two S’s I always guide my clients towards for their meals.
So that, in brief, is the strategy. First, you focus on the process. You focus on sustainability. You focus on making sustainable lifestyle changes rather than seeing your diet as a six-week period of suffering to get abs for the summer or to fit into your wedding dress. When you have established a good process and you are focused on the journey rather than the destination, then you will keep dieting until you are below your optimal body fat level. You will notice because at that point you will realize that it’s not worth it to be this lean. Only then can you decide to move up a little bit in body fat level and be truly happy with where you are, because it is now a choice. That’s the way you will really know what your optimal body fat level is.
Now, to back this up with some concrete numbers, Let’s look at the science of how your body fat level influences your health and your performance. For your health, the number one thing that you need to know is that there is clear scientific consensus that for most individuals, fat loss is incredibly good for your health. If we look at research on centenarians, people across the age of 100, they will almost always be relatively lean and having had consumed a relatively low energy intake throughout their lives. Energy restriction is by far the number one candidate for anti-aging. It’s the number one thing that we see, especially in animal research, that actually makes animals live longer. Even exercise is not nearly as potent based on most research.
We also see this acutely in health biomarkers, and you can observe it in yourself, in your blood work. If you lose a substantial amount of body fat, I can almost guarantee you that most of your blood work will be better. Your cholesterol will probably be lower. Your insulin resistance will probably be lower. If you had high levels of inflammation, they will probably be lower. Your heart rate is going to be lower. If you had high blood pressure, it will also likely be lower.
However, there is such a thing as being too lean. We even have essential body fat levels because they are, guess what? Essential. However, this is very, very little. In men, this is just a few percent, and in women, it’s maybe 10 to 12%. And these are real body fat levels, not what your caliper measurements or something say, because they will routinely underestimate body fat levels.
To give you an idea of what body fat percentages really look like based on laboratory-grade measurements, rather than social media, these images where people just slap some numbers on some images, You can look at this video.
While truly essential body fat levels are very low, our health starts deteriorating on some measures at a much higher point already. In fact, if we look at the most famous research on BMI, there is a famous J-curve. This J curve would suggest that the optimal BMI, based on observations of health effects and mortality and people’s BMI, the optimal BMI might be as high as 22. This would suggest that anything below 20% for body fat in men, 30% or something for women would already be the point at which going leaner starts hurting your health.
However, these data are horribly flawed. Statistically, these data suffer from problems known as residual confounding and reverse causality. For example, smoking, malnourishment and certain diseases lower people’s appetite and make them a lot less healthy. These individuals, based on BMI, register as having a low BMI and very poor health. So they confound the data and they make it seem like a low BMI is bad. However, what’s actually bad is being malnourished, having a terminal disease, or smoking. A particularly large confounder, which is especially relevant for us lifters, is muscle mass.
BMI captures two opposing relationships. Generally speaking, people with higher fat-free mass, more muscle mass, are healthier, stronger. And more muscular people die later in life. They are harder to kill. This is literally what the data show. Leaner people are generally also healthier. These function in opposing directions when it comes to BMI. So someone might have a low BMI because they have very low levels of muscle mass.
And these days, ironically, there is something called sarcopenic obesity, which is essentially the formal term for being skinny fat. It means that someone has too little muscle and too much fat. These individuals might not have a very high BMI, but they are particularly unhealthy. When we correct for muscularity, or at least fat-free mass, we see that the negative correlation with low BMI and poor health disappears. Individuals with a low BMI but sufficient levels of muscle mass are not unhealthier than individuals with a more moderate BMI.
To put some hard numbers on this, we can look at the 2022 meta-analysis of 35 cohort studies and 924,000 participants. The researchers looked at the relationship between body fat percentage and all-cause mortality, our overall chance of dying. The researchers found that when you just lump all of the data together, there is indeed the famous J-curve. However, when you correct for baseline disease states, again referring back to things like cancer that result in very low levels of body fat but are clearly the cause of poor health, the J-curve disappeared. There was no longer any evidence of negative health effects at lower body fat levels. The data showed that body fat percentage had very little relationship with health up to 20%, and thereafter started increasing very predictably.
However, this pooled men and women. Men and women have very different optimal body fat levels. Women have an almost 10% higher essential fat level, and to convert a body fat percentage from men to women, you can roughly add 10. At lower body fat levels, it’s closer to 8. And at higher body fat levels, it might be closer to 12. But roughly 10 does the job. So what is 10% body fat for a guy is roughly 20% body fat for a woman.
The researchers unfortunately didn’t disentangle this relationship between men and women, so I did it for them. I treated the 20% in the overall sample as a weighted average with 80% men. Based on that, we get an upper end of the ideal body fat range of 17% for men and 30% for women. We can also look at the sex-specific J-curves that the researchers found and then reduce it by 5%, because that was the average effect of excluding baseline disease. And based on that method, again, we get approximately 17% as the ideal upper end of the body fat range for men and 30% for women.
However, no matter how statistically optimal or nerdy we get with the data, these are still observational data. One solution to this and all of the confounders that come with observational data is Mendelian randomization. This is what a study by Hu et al. did in the UK. Mendelian randomization functions as a type of natural experiment-ish by assuming that the genes we get at conception are random. This is largely true. The genes we get from our parents at conception are basically random. At least between unrelated individuals,
we can assume this. Some of these genes are associated with higher body fat levels. So by looking at the relationship between these genes and therefore indirectly body fat levels, we can get an essentially randomized sample and sort of a randomized trial of what the effect is of body fat on all-cause mortality and longevity. The researchers concluded, “Genetically determined fat mass is causally and linearly associated with mortality.” There was no J-curve in individuals that did not have a high-risk lifestyle. So in us exercising and generally healthy individuals, there was essentially no evidence of being too lean.
Another way to look at these data is to look at health biomarkers. And the 2022 review concluded that the same degree of calorie restriction and the same amount of weight loss have multiple beneficial effects on health outcomes in individuals without obesity, similar to those observed in individuals with obesity. So this goes back to the health markers improving no matter how lean you are. The benefits are generally greater in individuals with more body fat. If you have insulin resistance and you lose a lot of fat, you will no longer have insulin resistance, probably. And that’s a huge upside. However, if you’re already very lean, you already have good insulin sensitivity, then getting leaner will still improve your insulin sensitivity more, but it’s probably not as clinically relevant.
There is one class of biomarkers that does deteriorate very clearly at low body fat levels, though. Hormones, specifically anabolic hormones. Any physique competitor can tell you that while they may look the best on stage at a very, very shredded body fat level, they feel terrible. Libido goes absolutely down the drain. And in the case of natural competitors, they often have castrate-level levels of testosterone. It’s very common for both men and women to have clinically low levels of testosterone and estrogen when they are in contest shape. In women, amenorrhea, the disappearance of the menstrual cycle, also generally occurs well before this point. This is a clear warning sign. There’s also an increase in cortisol production, which generally makes people more stress sensitive. Again, anyone who has competed can tell you that being that lean is very stressful indeed.
However, I would stress that if you’re not competing in a physique show, almost all of these metrics again improve up to roughly 12% body fat for men, and roughly the point at which you get any irregularities in the menstrual cycle, if you had a cycle to begin with as a woman.
High body fat levels, at least in men, are just as bad for your testosterone level. You have an enzyme called aromatase, and it’s made by adipose tissue, your fat mass. The more fat mass you have, the more aromatase it produces, the more of your testosterone it converts into estrogen. So the higher your body fat level, the worse the ratio gets between male and female sex hormones. That’s why at very high levels of body fat, men can actually become hypogonadal and even develop things like gyno. So they literally get breast tissue formation because the ratio of testosterone to estrogen, male to female sex hormone, is very off. In women, these sex hormones are produced directly in the ovaries and the adrenals. So there’s no negative effect of high body fat levels on testosterone production. But there are some trends in general for estrogen levels to be optimal in the range of roughly 21 to 31% body fat.
We get a similar picture if we look at data on fertility. Above a BMI of 18.5, there is a negative relationship between fertility and BMI. Especially above a BMI of 25, we see very negative effects on fertility. If we convert these BMIs to body fat percentage using the Deurenberg formula for a healthy 21-year-old, which is basically the peak level of health, we get a roughly optimal body fat level of 10.7% for men and 21.5% for women.
If we put all of these data together, I think they support the meta-analytic finding that the upper end of the optimal range for health outcomes is about 17% for men and 30% for women. At roughly 10% body fat for men and 20% body fat for women, things probably start taking a turn for the worse, but this is actually not entirely sure. Well-being most likely suffers. Libido suffers. Stress levels go up. But it’s not certain if this is actually bad in terms of longevity. Energy restriction still has many positive effects on health biomarkers. And this might be a case of quality versus quantity of life.
But who cares about your health? Let’s talk about something much more important: your gains. There is good reason, at least theoretically, to believe that there is an optimal range of body fat for your gains. Specifically, if we look at research on recovery capacity, we see that overweight individuals recover more slowly from a given workout and they suffer more muscle damage than leaner individuals. Low body fat levels also impair recovery, at least in women, based on the data we have. Body fat percentages of 14 to 15% in women are also associated with a longer time to recover from a given workout than being a little bit higher in body fat. The data on recovery capacity are, predictably, a lot more sparse than the data on health, anabolic hormone levels and fertility. However, they all point to roughly the same range of 10 to 20% for men and 20 to 30% for women, very roughly speaking.
Recovery capacity likely limits how much total volume you can handle, and in turn, it may affect your gains. However, most people are nowhere near the maximum tolerable recovery capacity. Most people’s training volumes are just not high. They are constrained by effort or time. So in most studies, to my surprise, body fat does not have any effect on muscle growth.
There is an effect on strength development, with multiple studies finding reduced strength development in overweight individuals versus leaner individuals. But it’s also questionable if this would apply to someone who is already well trained and relatively lean, even if they have a higher body fat level. So overall, there doesn’t seem to be much direct effect on your gains of your body fat level.
This is in contrast to what you would expect based on some of the P-ratio data, and we do see evidence of anabolic resistance. Overweight individuals, they have less protein synthesis after meals and after workouts. According to some research, they have higher levels of inflammation, and very high levels of inflammation have also been linked to less muscle growth. However, none of these factors seem to directly significantly influence muscle growth. For those interested in this topic in more detail, I made a previous video here conceding that I was wrong about high body fat levels being negative for muscle growth.
So if we put all of these data on anabolic hormone levels, fertility, health outcomes and performance and our gains together, what do we get? We get decent convergence. And if I would have to put hard numbers on it, setting aside personal preference and individual differences, I would say that roughly, the ideal body fat range for these outcomes for most individuals is going to be 9 to 17% for men and 19 to 28% for women, so roughly 10 to 20 for men and 20 to 30 for women.
An actually very simple way to summarize all of these results is that the optimal body fat range is simply the range in which you have a flat tummy. Abdominal fat is by far the most detrimental form of fat for your health. It is the visceral fat, the fat around our organs, that is the most detrimental for organ functioning. And impaired organ functioning is the real negative health effect of higher body fat levels. As long as you have a flat tummy, and in particular, if you have access to some scan that tells you what your visceral fat level is, as long as that is low, you’re probably not at significant risk from your body fat level for your health.
Women with a natural regular menstrual cycle also have an inbuilt warning mechanism. If their cycle starts becoming irregular, that is probably the point in which their body fat percentage is trending too low for optimal health, or at least fertility and anabolic hormone levels.
These body fat ranges also seem to correspond with what is natural for our bodies from an evolutionary perspective. For example, if we look at the Hadza hunter-gatherers, one of the last remaining populations on Earth of hunter-gatherers, we see that the average level of body fat in men is 13.5%, and that of women is 20.9%, very much squarely in line with the ideal ranges based on the scientific data. However, I would note that these are modern populations, so they already have access to things like smoking. So you could argue that the ideal body fat level in truly ancestral times, but being well fed, so normal nourishment, would still be actually a little bit lower than this.
Now, as much as I like to geek out over the optimal body fat ranges, statistically speaking, based on the scientific data, I would really stress that there is a big range here for both men and women that leaves a lot of room for personal preference. It’s also not like if you go outside of this average optimal range, then something bad will happen. So there is lots of leeway for personal preference.
And big picture, what I found in my coaching experience of actually getting people to their optimal body fat range, really, the method that works the best is focusing on the process, getting lean in a sustainable manner, and then getting to a point at which you conclude that you’re experiencing negative effects of being too lean. How many of these negative effects you experience is very much the result of how good a dieter you are.
If you try to get lean on a diet of highly processed foods, you’re always hungry and you’re just supplementing some vitamins because you think that will take care of your health, you will probably feel terribly. That’s not just the result of being too lean. That is also the result of having a poor diet. So the better your diet, the more nourishing it is, the more nutrients you’re getting, the more fruits, veggies, lean protein sources you’re getting in there, the better you will feel, the higher your appetite is, and the more satisfying your diet is, the easier it will be to tolerate that diet. So if you’re satiated and satisfied, you will tolerate a much lower body fat level, typically, than someone that isn’t, because just being hungry alone will already cause you to feel poorly.
That said, you can roughly diagnose being too lean based on decreasing libido, increasing stress sensitivity, and generally having lower well-being because in the end, that is the thing that matters most. So simply by trial and error and crossing the point at which you experience these negative side effects and then going back up, that I think for most people, is the best way to find out what their optimal body fat percentage is and be truly happy with it and content, without FOMO and without looking at other people and thinking, “Oh, wouldn’t it be great if I had their body fat level?”
We like to look at other people and we see the benefits, but we don’t see the costs. Experiencing the costs of low body fat directly is the best way, in my experience, to rid yourself of the jealousy, the FOMO, the envy of other people that are leaner, because you’ve concluded for yourself that it is not worth it.
So for many individuals, this is how you find your optimal body fat level. You focus on the journey, the process, and sustainably getting as lean as you can. At some point, you will experience the negative side effects of being too lean. This means your optimal body fat level for you, for your well-being, is higher than this level. Once you’ve found this, you go up a little bit in body fat level, and you probably cycle around that body fat level with cut and bulk cycles if you want to put on more muscle mass. That’s how you find your individual optimal body fat level and truly be happy with it.
I hope that helps. And if you’re looking for an app that helps you with your training and your nutrition, then check out my MH Physique App with the link in the description. You’ll get a two-week free trial. See you next time.
Want more content like this?
Then get our free mini-course on muscle building, fat loss and strength.
By filling in your details you consent with our privacy policy and the way we handle your personal data.